Who's watching American Idol?

[CTChin]

Well...isn't stage presence important? If singing were everything, Brittany whatever her name wouldn't be so famous. o.k. well...having a wild personal life helps too LOL BUT her concerts sell out. Go figure...

Rock is my first love. They had better be good this week!

 

[Rebecca]

Adam actually doesn't have a large range. Adam sings falsetto and nothing in the low tenor range.

He doesn't go low, but he goes unearthly high.

He has stage presence because he's been on the stage. Wicked is a play and he's part of the chorus. Plus he's been singing at a locale cabaret for quite sometime.
I find myself admiring Kris and Matt as they sang and played instruments. That is a big thing with me. Just standing up there and singing isn't as big as singing and playing the guitar and or piano. That kind of artistery blows me away.

I don't necessarily think its fair to cast Adam's stage presence aside simply because he has gained it over years of practice. Kris and Matt have years of practice with instruments, and Danny most likely has years of practice with whatever makes him special.

I wonder what rock week will bring. I wonder way Slash is a mentor? He doesn't sing.
He should do the best? Allison because she sings rock. Who should not do so well? Kris but we'll see

I'm really curious! Slash is probably the most "rocker-y" person they could get on the show. This night was made for Adam and Allison. I fear for Kris because I do like him well enough. I don't really like Allison's voice, and I think that rock night is the only thing it is really suited for.

 

[LannyCoop]

also apparently this week they are singing duets!
two and two, but the pairs are unknown haha
should be interesting..

 

[Rebecca]

also apparently this week they are singing duets!
two and two, but the pairs are unknown haha
should be interesting..

Kris and Adam singing Under Pressure would make my life. Well, my Tuesday anyways.

 

[tunes]

Noooo - Hands off Elvis and hands off Queen. Please, don't wish that on me, not Queen, my all time favorite band with no one in the world who can EVER compare to Freddie Mercury.

 

[searchand_dstry]

I didn't mean to start a huge debate lo. I won't post about Adam again!

I'm w/ Peggy on this.. no Elvis, no Queen. I don't care how much I like any of these contestants.. any songs by them would be ruined. I'm a huge David Cook fan but he had to sing "I don't wanna miss a thing", by Aerosmith and lost major points in my book.

To be honest, I would love to hear Adam and Danny do a duet if they actually do the duets. Danny with his low range and Adam with his high? I think they would harmonize very well together actually. Or maybe I'm insane, who knows.

 

[Rebecca]

To be honest, I would love to hear Adam and Danny do a duet if they actually do the duets. Danny with his low range and Adam with his high? I think they would harmonize very well together actually. Or maybe I'm insane, who knows.

:hilarious:. I just tried to picture it.

 

[searchand_dstry]

:hilarious:. I just tried to picture it.

Like I said, maybe I'm insane!

 

[Rebecca]

I just could NOT see it working, and every time I imagine it my face looks just like that emoticon.

 

[LannyCoop]

haha yeah i hope they do have duets!
thats what i hear, lets hope haha
i wish they each did a duet with one another
that would be cool haha

 

[Rebecca]

I actually don't like the idea of duets because I want two Adam songs, not one and a half!

 

[seachin]

are they going to bring back Tatiana to balance out the sexes for the duets?

:laughitup:

 

[LannyCoop]

are they going to bring back Tatiana to balance out the sexes for the duets?

:laughitup:

HAHAHAHA Oh dear I hope not...

 

[Laurie]

Allison should sing Melissa Etheridge. Please Allison, please sing Melissa Etheridge. You could do justice to Somebody Bring Me Some Water, or I'm the Only One.
I have no idea what to pick for anyone else. If Adam was to do Queen I would hope he would do Who Wants To Live Forever if only to get the horrid sound of Kristy Lee Cooke butching the heck out of it on Idol last flipping year--OMG I could still puke just thinking of it.
No ideas for Danny or Kris, none at all actually. Bob Seeger really isn't rock but Danny good do some justice to Bob Seeger I think.
I know I keep saying it, but we'll just have to see
Wait! Joe Cocker You Are So Beautiful for Danny, but again not really rock.

 

[Sierrasmom97]

Wow! What can I say..ummm...My prediction...Adam & Allison are the final two. Was not impressed with the other two tonight at all.

 

[Ash]

They were all good tonight, but Danny and Kris are going to be the bottom two. It's really a tossup which goes home. This is honestly one of the first seasons were everyone has been worthy of the 'top 4'. I don't like Adam, and would HATE to see him win, but he'd deserve it just as much as any of the others.

 

[Sierrasmom97]

I thought Danny was horrible tonight..especially at the end of his performance.

 

[Laurie]

Adam and Allison will not be the final two. Allison's been in the bottom 3 way too many times to be in the final. Allison will probably go home tomorrow night, her fan base isn't as strong as the boys. But yes they are all deserving of the top 4. Allison should have sung Melissa Etheridge. Kris should not have done The Beatles.

 

[Spoof]

Somebody should have done Queen. I'm forever sad.

Otherwise the night was short of torture.

 

[seachin]

nooooo! Queen falls into the category of artists that can never be topped, so it would be suicide (and likely torture) if someone tried to sing Queen.