I agree about the Polly Pockets. When they came back out I was like what the heck, these aren't Polly Pockets! You can't even fit them in your pocket anymore. Geez, why keep the name if the idea is different? And the original Littlest Pet shops were awesome, I had tons of them. I think they always ruin things the second time around.
What I really miss is this local place we used to go to as kids. It was called Shakey's and was kind of like Chuck-E Cheese, only better. They had these awesome twisted fried things with sugar and cinnamon on the outside. I loved them. We would bring in our report cards and get so many tokens for A's. It's no longer around and hasn't been for years, be we always went there.
I also used to have a stuffed PuffaLump as a kid. When I have kids, I'm getting them those.
ETA: oh! And those Fisher Price Little people. Now they make them big so kids don't choke. I don't get it, if we all survived, why did they change everything. At the rate we're going, our kid's kids are going to live in bubbles..