Melissa
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2009
- Messages
- 1,736
Who's watching American Idol?
- Thread starter Godins Chinchillas
- Start date
Help Support Chinchilla & Hedgehog Pet Forum:
- Status
Laurie
I heart Leonard
Tonight I like Felicia Barton most. I like Scott because he's a hardluck story, but I didn't care for his Mandolin Rain tonight. I thought it was odd Simon commented on the lyrics--has Simon never heard MacArthur Park before? Talk about bizaare lyrics!
Nathaniel just drove me nuts. He did an awful rendition of Anything for Love--yikes!
Nathaniel just drove me nuts. He did an awful rendition of Anything for Love--yikes!
Ash
Trouble....
Nathaniel reminds me of my step-dad's annoying little brother who thinks he can sing but really, he can't. Too much of a shaky voice.
Laurie, I'm with you on your picks tonight, but overall, last week was my 'favorite'. It'll be interesting to see who goes on tomorrow night, and who're the wild cards on Thursday.
Laurie, I'm with you on your picks tonight, but overall, last week was my 'favorite'. It'll be interesting to see who goes on tomorrow night, and who're the wild cards on Thursday.
searchand_dstry
Well-known member
I'm sorry Melissa this isn't directed towards you.
*defensive mode on*
I don't understand why it's such a big deal about him being gay.
David Cook is very "close" with his band mates on tour.. I wonder if people exploited that about him before he won, he would've got voted off. Granted, it's not making out with guys, but many people have jumped to conclusions about it.
Idk, it just bothers me because I think it really hurts his chances of getting far with the way many Americans think. I happen to love him even if he does over do it sometimes, but I'd really like to see what he can do. Watching videos that aren't American Idol, I know he actually does have quite an amazing voice when he's not going all crazy!
If you hate him because you don't like his voice/attitude fine, but the gay thing is retarded.
*defensive mode off*
That was probably a really ridiculous pointless argument there, but I see so much of it everywhere on the web (LJ & other forums) & it's just annoying. :wacko:
Ash
Trouble....
Gag on a certain wildcard selection. Now, I'm confused. Do they sing tomorrow and the judges pick 4 of them or what?
Laurie
I heart Leonard
Well I have to say yes to Scott and Jorge but Lil Rounds--no. I liked Felicia much better. I'm pleased and upset with the wildcard selections. Ricky Braddy yes, Anoop yes, Tatiana--NO!
As for the whole Adam thing--here's the bottom line people. If you want to be famous someday, and it's clear Adam does, then you have to hold yourself at a higher standard than the rest of the world. Yes Bill Clinton this meant you. Yes Micheal Phelps this means you. You have to THINK! Is is wrong to be gay, no it's not wrong, will it hurt your chances with mainstream America, yes it will. This has been proving time and time again unless you're funny like Ellen or Rosie O'Donnell. Adam needed to think about the impact of his actions all over the internet. Look at poor David Hernandez from last year, he worked at a male strip club for men and got ousted well before his time. I mean come on David was a 1000 times better than Kristy Lee Cook.
So we'll have to see what happens, but honestly it wouldn't surprise me to see that Adam's off camera antics could hurt his chances--would it be a shame, yes, would it be surprising to me--no.
As for the whole Adam thing--here's the bottom line people. If you want to be famous someday, and it's clear Adam does, then you have to hold yourself at a higher standard than the rest of the world. Yes Bill Clinton this meant you. Yes Micheal Phelps this means you. You have to THINK! Is is wrong to be gay, no it's not wrong, will it hurt your chances with mainstream America, yes it will. This has been proving time and time again unless you're funny like Ellen or Rosie O'Donnell. Adam needed to think about the impact of his actions all over the internet. Look at poor David Hernandez from last year, he worked at a male strip club for men and got ousted well before his time. I mean come on David was a 1000 times better than Kristy Lee Cook.
So we'll have to see what happens, but honestly it wouldn't surprise me to see that Adam's off camera antics could hurt his chances--would it be a shame, yes, would it be surprising to me--no.
K
kaykay
Guest
I completely second this.
Who cares if Adam is gay? That makes absolutely no difference on my opinion that he isn't that good! He screams, he over acts, he is cocky. I don't like him, I don't like his voice.
If Tatiana goes through, I will most likely be done watching AI, because then VFTW.com will have proven it's point. That they only bring people in that they know will bring entertainment to the show, and not to actually choose talent, and that sucks.
If Tatiana goes through, I will most likely be done watching AI, because then VFTW.com will have proven it's point. That they only bring people in that they know will bring entertainment to the show, and not to actually choose talent, and that sucks.
Spoof
Kung Fu Chinny!
Will be an interesting show tonight... almost dreading it. Scott and Jorge sounded SO much better last night!
Sad thing is, she isn't the worst. She has a nice voice. I do not like her nor like to hear her talk, but I preferred her singing over Lil Rounds.
When they called her name I turned it off. Couldn't handle the blubbering. :vomit:
Sad thing is, she isn't the worst. She has a nice voice. I do not like her nor like to hear her talk, but I preferred her singing over Lil Rounds.
When they called her name I turned it off. Couldn't handle the blubbering. :vomit:
Stackie
I bite.
I'm probably going to miss the show tonight..
It's sad people are judging Adam because he's gay...Elton John is gay! Isn't Clay Aiken gay too??? They're both great singers and have obviously made it very far!
I was very, very mad that Tatiana made it. I thought her horrible annoying-ness was something I wouldn't have to bear anymore..ugh.
It's sad people are judging Adam because he's gay...Elton John is gay! Isn't Clay Aiken gay too??? They're both great singers and have obviously made it very far!
I was very, very mad that Tatiana made it. I thought her horrible annoying-ness was something I wouldn't have to bear anymore..ugh.
K
kaykay
Guest
Clay Aiken is gay...totally irrelevant to me, but just wanted to confirm what you said.
I muted Tatiana when she came on...she's SOOOO melodramatic. It's ridiculous. Tunes, I totally agree with what you said. And I said that about Sanjaya as well, but I still watched...I couldn't help it
I muted Tatiana when she came on...she's SOOOO melodramatic. It's ridiculous. Tunes, I totally agree with what you said. And I said that about Sanjaya as well, but I still watched...I couldn't help it
K
kare_bear
Guest
I thought we would be done with Tatiana, but no. You know the only reason she is through is becuase of being a drama llama. I loved when Simon acted out the theatrics she was doing.
Hopefully she wont make it further, does ANYONE (but her) like her? Yes she can sing but an obnoxious personality can completely wreck it.
Hopefully she wont make it further, does ANYONE (but her) like her? Yes she can sing but an obnoxious personality can completely wreck it.
Godins Chinchillas
Godin's Chinchillas
I cannot stand her. We fast forward through her. I was actually disappointed that Ju'not (sp) wasn't one of the wild cards. I liked him. My picks for this week were Jorge, LIL Round, and Scott...and they all made it.
I pray that Tatiana won't get pass the wild card. I really really really don't like her.
jessica
I pray that Tatiana won't get pass the wild card. I really really really don't like her.
jessica
S
Sierrasmom97
Guest
Woooohoooo...They got rid of Tatiyana!!!
Ash
Trouble....
WOAH! Twist at the end! Awesome.
Gee, thanks for those of us who haven't watched it yet because we are in different time zones!
Ash
Trouble....
Don't worry. Wait for the twist, Peggy :heart3:
Spoof
Kung Fu Chinny!
You're in my timezone, and it's done already!! Quit reading! :dance3:
And thank god T didn't make it@!@
Last edited:
Melissa
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2009
- Messages
- 1,736
Staff has to read threads.. Thats our job.. It is nice for some people so wait a couple hours for those of us that havent seen it yet.
- Status
