New Idol Judges

[Laurie]

Ellen's out--Kara's out--Simon's out--Paula--left

Who's in?
Randy Jackson, Jennifer Lopez and Stephen Tyler

UG! I'm pretty sure I will no longer watch the show.

 

[tunes]

Yeah, Stephen Tyler just isn't going to cut it as a judge, and J-Lo will try and pretend to be Paula. I think Idol will have it's last season, but I won't be watching it.

 

[leni]

I haven't watched it in a long time, so I guess I won't be missing it anyway

 

[kimbt622]

What a strange line-up of judges. I agree Peg, it'll definitely be the last season. My dad also said he heard Jessica Simpson might be a judge. UHHH? not good choices Fox.

 

[ruoc]

Really? Who came up with those choices? They should have had an American Idol Judge competition. Now that would have been worth watching, can you imagine the bloopers?

 

[AmandaDi]

I will still watch it Im sure, for curiousity if nothing else! I think Harry C. Jr. would have been a good choice!

 

[InkedupTara]

MMM Harry is YUMMY!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Stackie]

I wish Adam Lambert would have been a judge so I could at least have something to look at. I'm not happy with the new judges at all. *sigh*

 

[Laurie]

I would have watched if Harry or Chris Isaak were judges--I don't care to see J Lo or Steven Tyler. What about Cher, Nigel! What about Richard Marx? What the heck this show is going to bomb big time!

 

[Snickers]

I wish the guy from Doogie Hoosier (Patrick something) was a judge. He was a judge for a day or two during the auditions.

I guess I will not be watching with those judges.

 

[Nickv0195]

I think that Kelly Clarkson , Carrie Underwood, and Amy Lee should have been judges

 

[Marie5656]

I do not watch the show, but I heard somewhere that Kara is out because J-Lo wanted to be the only female judge. I still think Brett Michaels would have been better. He is a good musician, and has had judging experience when he judged Nashville Star.

 

[DOLLY<3]

You know, in a quirky way, I think this could work. I'm sorry for all of you who don't like him, but Stephen Tyler's era was imho the best for music and lately there have been a lot of rockers sprouting up, so I think he'd be good on that front... If they would've gotten rid of randy I would've been happy because I swear.. if he says YO YO, DOG, or LISTEN UP one more time I may pull my hair out. Ellen had no idea what she was talking about, and Simon was just ... Simon, him I'll miss the most. I'm forgetting Kara.. for good reason I like the singers, not the judges, so I'll fast forward through most of the critiquing anyway. lol funny ... I'm putting up a fuss over American Idol, and I've never even watched Canadian Idol... how patriotic of me

 

[Laurie]

Snickers, Neil Patrick Harris WOULD be a funny judge for sure! Yo-Yo Dolly lol! I just had to put that in there dawg!

Today the rumor mill is saying J-Lo is out. Hopefully that doesn't mean Mariah Carey is in.

I think Shania Twain would be very good as well as Jamie Foxx! Jamie is always a great guest judge.

I don't want Bret Michaels doing it only for the fact I wish the guy would slow down, smell the roses and spend time with his girlfriend and kids--he nearly died, he needs to do nothing but hang with family for a bit.

Now if Nick Lachey wanted to be a hunky judge I have no problem with that!

 

[Stackie]

I heard on the news tonight that J-Lo is no longer going to be a judge.

 

[DOLLY<3]

Please no Mariah Carey, throw in Ann Wilson from Heart woot woot.

 

[Laurie]

Ann or Nancy Wilson--I concur!

 

[AmandaDi]

Also heard that JLo was out ... said her demands were too high! I would think Mariah would be just as bad, or worse!!!

Neil Patrick Harris or Richard Marx would be great too!

Can't think of a fabulous female right now...

 

[Spoof]

I am just happy Kara left, I have never disliked a host so much. Might actually continue watching it now that she has gone.

 

[Ash]

I'm hoping Shania takes the spot if she's really been offered it. I think she'd do well.