Let me just say at the outset: I am most definitely not against keeping animals in captivity - since I keep & love my chinchillas dearly I'd be more than a bit of a hypocrite if I did, wouldn't I?
edit: just read the above post and i don't know, this could be the case for many captive animals yes, but to say that repetitive behavior applies to all of these situations seems too generalizing. Every chin has a unique personality and while these behaviors could exhibit stress, how do you explain it when it happens in a not particularly stressful environment. My kids were definitely never bored or seemed stressed in any fashion. His breeder told me he did backflips ( this being even at a few months old) and he continued to do them throughout his life.... it wasn't something he would do continuously on end manically but it was def one of his traits.
Hmmm.... I'm curious, did you read any of the articles I linked or watch the videos?
Yes, my post is generalising but I'll draw your attention to the fact that people will also generalise about how crazy whites are, how diva-esque black velvets are, how laid back some ebonies are ............ there are exceptions to every rule & we talk in/of stereotypes all the time.
Chins don't
have to be stressed to perform ARBs - I know of some very spoiled chins who live the life O'Reilly & still display repetitive behaviours.
The fact remains that some behaviours are abnormal & should be addressed rather than labelled as normal or cute. They are not - captive animals will
always display adaptive behaviour (that, after all is the nature of captivity: it is not "natural" for the animal, no matter how hard we try to make it so) & some of it is considered positive, some of it is not. The key is differentiating between "good/bad" (for want of better words just now) & changing the "bad" & encouraging the "good".
The fact that we take some of the adaptive behaviours & mould them into "training" does not change the fundamental fact that they are adaptive behaviours or that we adapt their behaviour to (ostensively) meet our needs .........
One example of that is dog agility - dogs love to play & also to be stimulated physically & mentally - agility training meets both these needs & is an adaption of the "natural" behaviour of a dog. :thumbsup:
Surely our role as owners is to identify & understand the behaviours we see in the animals we choose to keep & to develop strategies to enhance their environment so that they can display as normal a behaviour pattern as possible? One of the dangers we see again & again on the forums is when someone projects human emotions & behaviours onto their chins - being able to do that with humour is one thing but then we should step back & see behaviour for what it actually is.
Not everyone will agree but, to me,
any kind of repetitive behaviour needs careful attention & consideration - some people will decide not to do anything & will, in fact, reward that behaviour, ingraining it deeper into the animal - in many cases it is probably not considered detrimental to the animal or the owner. For example, a chin which rattles the bars of the cage for attention & who then gets let out will continue to do so because it is rewarded - nothing wrong in that, is there? But, in terms of behaviour, essentially it is still considered an ARB. There are degrees of everything.
An example from another species - a dog which exhibits separation anxiety - a dog which howls & barks when left will continue to do so if that behaviour is rewarded by the humans coming back because they howl/bark ..........
Animal behaviour is fascinating & complex - consider the discussions/debates/arguments/venting which happens whenever a captive animal attacks or kills a human - what a minefield that is!
Personally I love watching animal behaviour & trying to understand what is happening on their level.